New Ideas About Halting Diabetes
When Neal Barnard was growing
up in the 1960s, he witnessed the
devastation of diabetes firsthand
through his father, a physician who
specialized in the disease. "I can't
tell you now many people I saw
going blind, suffering heart attacks
and having their legs amputated," he
says. Barnard's father had one treatment
to offer patients--insulin. Now
that Barnard is an M.D. himself, he's
trying a different approach. He's
putting patients on an aggressive
vegetarian diet in the hope of actually
reversing type 2 [adult-onset] diabetes.
"I want to turn the clock back
so that patients can go off diabetes
medications," he says.
That may not be as farfetched as it
sound. The famed diet doctor Dean
Ornish has shown that a strict lowfat
diet and exercise can reverse
heart disease. Why not diabetes? A
leading risk factor for Type 2 diabetes
is obesity. As Americans girth
has expanded, disease rates have spiralled.
Today, 16 million Americans
have this disorder, costing the United
States $100 billion a year. But new
research shows that diet and exercise
can not only help prevent the disease,
but also possibly delay its progression.
"With the right diet and fitness
framework, we might really be
able to modify the course of diabetes,"
says Dr. Francine Kaufman,
president of the American Diabetes
Association.
Diabetes is a progressive disease,
but lifestyle changes can help at
every stage. People with diabetes
have trouble regulating blood sugar
levels. Normally, the naturally
occurring hormone insulin helps
move glucose out of the bloodstream
and into cells, which need the sugar
for energy. But in many obese
adults--and increasingly, overweight
teenagers--cells stop responding
properly to insulin. Blood sugar
build up and eventually damages
blood vessels and other tissues.
Although supplemental insulin and
insulin-boosting drugs are needed in
advanced diabetes, patients with
mild cases can often normalize their
blood sugar with diet and exercise.
The ADA advocates a diet of whole
grains, fruits and vegetables with
smaller portions of lean meat, fish,
and dairy.
But Barnard, an adjunct professor
at George Washington University,
contends that to see reversals in diabetes,
more drastic steps are necessary.
In a small pilot study, he put
seven patients on a strict vegan diet.
Patients derived 75 percent of their
calories from carbohydrates in the
form of whole grains, vegetables,
fruit and beans. Meat, cheese, and
eggs were off-limits, since some scientists
believe their saturated fat and
high calories increase insulin resistance.
After 12 weeks, the vegan
patients showed an average 28 percent
reduction in fasting blood sugar
versus a 12 percent reduction in the
control patients who followed the
ADAdiet. "Most of the vegan group
were able to reduce their medications,"
adds Barnard. "None of the
controls did." But such a small trial
is hardly conclusive, and Barnard is
repeating the trial now in a larger
group of 68.
Barnard did not include an exercise
regimen in his study, because he
wanted to isolate the effects of diet.
But for people with diabetes, exercise
is crucial; active muscles absorb
glucose more efficiently. The combination
of diet and exercise is more
powerful than either one alone and
may be even more effective than
drugs, at least in preventing diabetes.
A landmark trial of 3,234 pre-diabetic
patients last year found that a lowcalorie
low-fat diet and moderate
exercise--30 minutes five times a
week--reduced new diabetes cases
by 58 percent over a three-year period.
By contrast the drug metformin,
which boosts insulin sensitivity,
reduced new cases by only 31 percent.
Even with diet and exercise, not
everyone will be able to roll back
diabetes. After a certain point, the
body simply cannot produce enough
insulin. In such advanced cases,
however, diet and exercise may still
help prevent some of the worst
effects o the disease--heart attacks
and strokes. The NIH is launching a
12-year 5,000-patient study to test
the idea. If it proves successful, it
would not only reduce the nation's
$100 billion burden, but also relieve
untold human suffering.
(Newsweek, January 20, 2003, - by
Anne Underwood)
|